Emily Blunt and John Krasinski had a rare date night in New York City on Friday night, and they took to Instagram to let people know just how good it was. The couple saw illusionist Derren Brown’s Broadway show Secret, which Krasinski is now recommending to his 2.8 million followers.

“Oh my Lordy! Just had my mind BLOWN by the one and only @derrenbrown tonight!” he wrote. “If you’re in NYC and want to see one of the greatest shows ever…This is the one!”

Brown also shared his own photo with the couple, who he was thrilled to meet, writing, “I am meeting the most extraordinary people who come and see the show. People I have no business being around. But it’s ever so nice and occasionally wonderful, like last night. These two.”

While the couple often work together, they rarely share their private life with the public. Last month, Krasinski opened up about working with his wife and how they make it work.

“I gotta say it just sort of happens organically. It’s one of those things where I was a huge fan of hers before I even met her, so I continue to be a huge fan of hers in everything she does,” he told E! News. “So we’re just extremely supportive. We get what the job is and that you gotta travel and do some stuff, but it’s always about coming back home and being together. It’s the most important thing.”